Failure to Assess Medical History Leads to Legal Action

Case Study

Marc Leffler, DDS, Esq.
January 16, 2025

Reading time: 8 minutes

Male dentist using digital tablet to consult a female patient.

Initial Events

An experienced general dentist (we’ll call him Dr. A) on the verge of retirement was greeted as he entered his office one morning by a process server who handed him a Summons and Complaint — it alleged that he caused the wrongful death of one of his patients, and had no further details.  At first glance, the dentist had vague recall of the patient whose estate filed the suit, but he did not remember any problems with the patient’s treatment which was over a year earlier.

He immediately pulled the patient’s chart – all handwritten – to review it, in advance of getting in touch with his dental malpractice carrier.  He was soon contacted by the assigned attorney representing him, and they agreed to meet the following day, as strict time limits existed regarding when a response on behalf of the dentist needed to be filed.

The dentist’s attorney contacted the attorney for the plaintiff to try to understand the underlying circumstances.  The plaintiff’s attorney conveyed that this was a simple case: Dr. A had extracted the patient’s tooth, which led to a significant post-operative bleeding event on the day of extraction, which caused the need for emergency transport to a local hospital, where the patient (age 67) died.  The plaintiff’s attorney suggested a quick settlement to save the family a stressful legal process.  As would later be learned, those reported case facts were all true, but critical events – which would guide the entirety of the litigation and its resolution – were left out of the description.

Treatment Background

Dr. A and his attorney went through the dental chart together to work through the course of treatment.  The patient initially presented several years prior for a check-up.  The dentist, who never had a medical history form as part of his chart, verbally discussed with his new patient any existing medical conditions: he was taking Coumadin due to a history of a “blood clot” (deep vein thrombosis), and metoprolol for hypertension.  Dr. A simply noted “Coumadin and HBP” in the chart for medical history, and called the patient’s physician after determining that the patient needed a deep scaling; the physician said a subsequent dental appointment should be scheduled a week later rather than treating that day. 

Unbeknownst to the dentist, the physician then told his patient to stop taking Coumadin for 4 days prior to that upcoming dental appointment and to obtain a blood test the day prior to it. The patient did exactly that, and his physician advised him to tell Dr. A that he may proceed with the planned procedure, and that the patient should re-start his Coumadin 2 days after the scaling.  The patient reported to Dr. A only that his physician had told him that he may proceed, but he did not mention, nor was he asked about, Coumadin stoppage and testing.  All went forward without complication.

The patient next appeared nearly a year later for what would be his final visit, complaining of a loose, annoying upper first molar. Radiograph and exam demonstrated a periodontally hopeless tooth, so the dentist suggested extraction and the patient agreed.  Dr. A asked the patient how his health was, and he responded – according to Dr. A – that he was doing well, but his blood pressure medication had been changed to better control it.  That was the entirety of the conversation, although the subsequent medical records clearly reveal that he continued to take Coumadin as of that time.

Dr. A routinely extracted tooth #14 and debrided the associated granulation tissue.  He applied gauze pressure to the site and good hemostasis was achieved.  The patient was discharged home with a packet of extra gauze, and instructions to place additional gauze on the site as needed.  The patient’s son, who knew his father was going to the dentist that day, was unable to reach his father that evening, so he drove to his father’s house, to find him conscious but lying on the floor with blood seeping out of his mouth.  An ambulance was called to transport the patient to a local hospital.

At the hospital, the patient was admitted and transfused.  Laboratory values showed that the patient had an elevated prothrombin time, as would be expected in a Coumadinized patient.  A hematologist managed the patient’s anti-coagulation and was able to medically stabilize him within a fairly short time.  However, the laboratory studies also, unfortunately, revealed that the patient had an advanced, aggressive form of leukemia.  After a work-up and a discussion of treatment options, the patient agreed to start a course of chemotherapy, but he stopped it several days later due to side effects that he found intolerable.  Palliative therapy was provided at the hospital, but he soon passed away.

Once defense counsel obtained all relevant medical records and had experts review them, it was clear that Dr. A was negligent in failing to take an adequate medical history at the extraction visit — so as to have ignored the important fact that the patient was taking Coumadin, thereby leading to the bleeding event which hospitalized him.  But, it was equally clear that it was the entirely unrelated leukemia which caused the patient’s death.

Defense counsel contacted the plaintiff’s attorney, asking for discontinuance of the action because there was no good faith basis to maintain a wrongful death claim.  Plaintiff’s counsel argued that it was the dentist’s negligence which put him in the hospital due to uncontrolled bleeding, but the dentist’s attorney reminded him that the only claim was for wrongful death, which was not caused by the dentist, and that the statute of limitations had expired as to any potential bleeding-related claim, thereby precluding its addition at that point.  Ultimately, the plaintiff’s attorney relented, and discontinued the case.

However, the estate executor and plaintiff – the patient’s son – was upset that Dr. A was not held accountable for his negligent actions, so he filed a disciplinary complaint with the State.  Disciplinary bodies, unlike courts in malpractice litigation, do not consider what result came of a dentist’s claimed improper actions, but only whether those actions constituted professional (i.e. appropriate) or unprofessional conduct — the latter of which is sanctionable.  In this case, the disciplinary agency determined that Dr. A had acted improperly with regard to his record-keeping, specifically relating to his taking and recording of the patient’s medical history at the extraction visit.  The dentist was given a stayed suspension and a fine, and required to take continuing education classes in the subjects of history taking and dental charting during his next license renewal cycle.

Takeaways

This case demonstrates the importance of immediate reporting to the malpractice carrier, so that counsel may be immediately assigned — not only for the purpose of filing timely response papers, but to allow counsel to evaluate the lawsuit’s pleadings to assess what the claims specifically are.  Here, defense counsel was able to determine that the sole claim involved a wrongful causing of death, so that the review of the dentist’s chart and the subsequent medical records could be focused toward assessment and defense of the pending legal claims.  Yes, this patient died after dental treatment – albeit well after that treatment, a fact not initially disclosed by plaintiff’s attorney – but it turned out to be unrelated to the dentist’s care. For a valid claim in dental malpractice, there must be negligent treatment which directly caused the injuries claimed.

A common theme explored in legal case studies is the importance of proper record-keeping, which simply cannot be emphasized enough.  In this case, even if Dr. A did appropriately discuss medical history with his patient, he did not record having done so. Therefore, a reasonable inference may be drawn, including by a jury, that what was not recorded did not happen.  While that issue did not play out in this malpractice case scenario, it was the focus of the discipline levied against the dentist. 

Dentists would be well served to present their patients with printed medical history forms, which are then supplemented through a back-and-forth discussion, so nothing of relevance is omitted.  Simply asking a patient, “Are you in good health?”, as is done with surprising frequency, leaves it to the patient to evaluate and report what conditions might be significant. Furthermore, a patient’s failure to disclose on a written form carries far more defense weight before a jury than conflicting stories about what was or was not said.  Similarly, if physician consultations are requested, a written response from the physician, or minimally, a contemporaneously documented conversation between dentist and physician will eliminate issues associated with gaps in patient recall and/or which may confuse a patient.

While the purpose of this case study is not to dictate what actions dentists should or should not take in given situations, it is worth pointing out that it is far from uncommon that dentists are caught in situations which would appropriately differentiate between the initial stoppage of bleeding and the development of a stable clot.  As a general principle, blood initially stops due to the actions of platelets, whereas stable fibrin clots are created after the body later completes a coagulation cascade; drugs such as aspirin and conditions such as thrombocytopenia may interfere with the formation of an initial platelet plug, while medications like Coumadin and conditions like hemophilia interfere with the clotting cascade to inhibit clot formation later.  Here, the hemostasis achieved in Dr. A’s office was attributable to platelets (which are essentially unaffected by Coumadin), but the platelet plug which is normally replaced by a clot was not so replaced in this case, thereby accounting for the delay in the onset of bleeding. 

From a risk management perspective, it is always a good idea to regularly review medical conditions and medications, especially as they arise in treatment circumstances; it is never a problem to consult literature or field experts.

Finally, this case demonstrates the value of open communication and a strong professional relationship between dentist and defense counsel familiar with the subject matters at hand.

Note that this case presentation includes circumstances from several different closed cases, in order to demonstrate certain legal and risk management principles, and that identifying facts and personal characteristics were modified to protect identities. The content within is not the original work of MedPro Group but has been published with consent of the author. Nothing contained in this article should be construed as legal, medical, or dental advice. Because the facts applicable to your situation may vary, or the laws applicable in your jurisdiction may differ, please contact your personal or business attorney or other professional advisors if you have any questions related to your legal or medical obligations or rights, state or federal laws, contract interpretation, or other legal questions.

			WP_Query Object
(
    [query] => Array
        (
            [post_type] => post
            [showposts] => 3
            [post__not_in] => Array
                (
                    [0] => 4053
                )

            [post_status] => publish
            [has_password] => 
            [cat] => 1365
        )

    [query_vars] => Array
        (
            [post_type] => post
            [showposts] => 3
            [post__not_in] => Array
                (
                    [0] => 4053
                )

            [post_status] => publish
            [has_password] => 
            [cat] => 1365
            [error] => 
            [m] => 
            [p] => 0
            [post_parent] => 
            [subpost] => 
            [subpost_id] => 
            [attachment] => 
            [attachment_id] => 0
            [name] => 
            [pagename] => 
            [page_id] => 0
            [second] => 
            [minute] => 
            [hour] => 
            [day] => 0
            [monthnum] => 0
            [year] => 0
            [w] => 0
            [category_name] => practice-more-safely
            [tag] => 
            [tag_id] => 
            [author] => 
            [author_name] => 
            [feed] => 
            [tb] => 
            [paged] => 0
            [meta_key] => 
            [meta_value] => 
            [preview] => 
            [s] => 
            [sentence] => 
            [title] => 
            [fields] => all
            [menu_order] => 
            [embed] => 
            [category__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [category__not_in] => Array
                (
                )

            [category__and] => Array
                (
                )

            [post__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [post_name__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [tag__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [tag__not_in] => Array
                (
                )

            [tag__and] => Array
                (
                )

            [tag_slug__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [tag_slug__and] => Array
                (
                )

            [post_parent__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [post_parent__not_in] => Array
                (
                )

            [author__in] => Array
                (
                )

            [author__not_in] => Array
                (
                )

            [search_columns] => Array
                (
                )

            [ignore_sticky_posts] => 
            [suppress_filters] => 
            [cache_results] => 1
            [update_post_term_cache] => 1
            [update_menu_item_cache] => 
            [lazy_load_term_meta] => 1
            [update_post_meta_cache] => 1
            [posts_per_page] => 3
            [nopaging] => 
            [comments_per_page] => 50
            [no_found_rows] => 
            [order] => DESC
        )

    [tax_query] => WP_Tax_Query Object
        (
            [queries] => Array
                (
                    [0] => Array
                        (
                            [taxonomy] => category
                            [terms] => Array
                                (
                                    [0] => 1365
                                )

                            [field] => term_id
                            [operator] => IN
                            [include_children] => 1
                        )

                )

            [relation] => AND
            [table_aliases:protected] => Array
                (
                    [0] => wp_term_relationships
                )

            [queried_terms] => Array
                (
                    [category] => Array
                        (
                            [terms] => Array
                                (
                                    [0] => 1365
                                )

                            [field] => term_id
                        )

                )

            [primary_table] => wp_posts
            [primary_id_column] => ID
        )

    [meta_query] => WP_Meta_Query Object
        (
            [queries] => Array
                (
                )

            [relation] => 
            [meta_table] => 
            [meta_id_column] => 
            [primary_table] => 
            [primary_id_column] => 
            [table_aliases:protected] => Array
                (
                )

            [clauses:protected] => Array
                (
                )

            [has_or_relation:protected] => 
        )

    [date_query] => 
    [request] => SELECT SQL_CALC_FOUND_ROWS  wp_posts.ID
					 FROM wp_posts  LEFT JOIN wp_term_relationships ON (wp_posts.ID = wp_term_relationships.object_id)
					 WHERE 1=1  AND wp_posts.ID NOT IN (4053) AND ( 
  wp_term_relationships.term_taxonomy_id IN (11)
) AND wp_posts.post_password = '' AND wp_posts.post_type = 'post' AND ((wp_posts.post_status = 'publish'))
					 GROUP BY wp_posts.ID
					 ORDER BY wp_posts.post_date DESC
					 LIMIT 0, 3
    [posts] => Array
        (
            [0] => WP_Post Object
                (
                    [ID] => 10800
                    [post_author] => 180159417
                    [post_date] => 2026-11-04 14:02:38
                    [post_date_gmt] => 2026-11-04 19:02:38
                    [post_content] => 






In this real-life case study, dentists will learn how a simple communication breakdown between offices led to the extraction of the wrong tooth and a malpractice lawsuit. Discover the roles that referral processes, informed consent, team communication, and treatment verification play in preventing wrong-site treatment and reducing liability.

Key Concepts

  • Wrong-tooth extraction results in lawsuit
  • Communication breakdown leads to treatment error
  • Preventing liability through verification procedures

Background Facts

Dr. Q is a restorative dentist in a suburban community. While she used to practice the full spectrum of general dentistry, the last few years have seen her focus exclusively on restorative cases, with patients needing all other areas of dental care being referred to other providers. P was a 37-year-old man who had been a patient of Dr. Q's for nearly a decade.

During a weekend soccer game, P "headed" the ball to one of his teammates, with the ball striking the right mid-face, somewhat lower than the forehead area he had intended. There was some lingering pain on P's face for the remainder of the game, but he did not think much of it. At dinner that evening, he found himself with shock-like discomfort emanating from his upper right teeth, although he could not pinpoint a specific tooth as the source. When the situation did not resolve by several days later, he presented to see Dr. Q.

When Dr. Q examined the quadrant, she noted tooth #2 to have a large 3-surface amalgam in place, but she could not elicit any abnormal responses through percussion or palpation. Nor could she find anything unusual on radiograph or with an explorer. On the other hand, #3, which was a virgin tooth, was tender to all modalities and it clinically exhibited a probable vertical MB root fracture beginning at the furcation and extending apically. Dr. Q concluded the tooth to be non-restorable, so she suggested its extraction – by an oral surgeon – with an implant and crown for replacement. Dr. Q entered her electronic note, explaining the situation regarding both teeth #2 and 3, and handing P a handwritten referral card, asking Dr. E, an oral and maxillofacial surgeon, to extract #3 and place a bone graft so that she (Dr. Q) could later place an implant and restore it.

Dr. Q's front desk staff member called Dr. E's office to say that "we're sending over a patient, P, for an extraction.” "OK.” Either before or during the short drive to see Dr. E, P misplaced or lost the referral card. At this point, all he knew was that an upper right tooth needed to come out. P "frantically" called Dr. Q's office to ask that a fax be sent to Dr. E with the information as to the tooth to be extracted. Dr. Q's office manager quickly scanned the newly written note from just a few minutes prior, focused solely on the first portion of the chart entry which stated that tooth #2 had a "large, old MOD amalgam,” presumed that was the tooth in need of treatment, and faxed "please ext tooth #2,” unsigned, on Dr. Q's letterhead. After taking a periapical radiograph of teeth #1-3 (distal half only of #3 captured), obtaining P's signature on a consent form for "extraction upper right molar,” and giving local anesthesia, Dr. E did exactly what the letter from Dr. Q asked him to do. A post-extraction periapical more clearly and completely showed tooth #3, adjacent to the new extraction site, with an apparent vertical MB root fracture.

Dr. E immediately called Dr. Q after realizing his error, and the two concluded that he ought to explain the event to P, and then extract tooth #3. Dr. E asked P to initial the newly modified consent form, which added the letter "s" to "molar.” P complied. Drs. Q and E would work together to provide 2 implants with 2 crowns, all at no cost. Those treatments later went forward uneventfully, with P being able to function without limitation, although he always worried about his dental future. (It is worth noting that P had been in family therapy – for totally unrelated reasons – prior to these events, but he began to talk extensively with his therapist about his upset over the dentistry, with all of that recorded in the therapy chart).

Legal Action

P was clearly aware that he would have no out-of-pocket expenses due to the wrongly extracted tooth. In fact, whereas he would have paid for the 1 implant and 1 crown for tooth #3 had there been no error, he no longer had to, based upon the goodwill gestures of both doctors. But it was no longer about money needed for the dentistry: he wanted to be compensated for the stress of the entire situation. P was unable to find an attorney willing to take his case against Drs. Q and E, so he decided to file a malpractice lawsuit in City Court, which in his jurisdiction, was a level higher than Small Claims and a level lower than the general trial court, and which readily enabled him to handle the case on his own, as a pro se litigant. The City Court's "DIY" web page set out the procedures to abide by, the most important of which was a reasonable degree of relaxation of rules of evidence. For example, copies of medical and dental records could be introduced without the author being present to testify about, and certify, them. A judge would preside and would render a verdict.

At the trial, both of the defendant doctors were represented by attorneys assigned to them by their malpractice insurers, as malpractice policies generally provide, regardless of the level of the court. P argued, essentially, that he was an unwitting victim, with no role in any wrongdoing, but with both doctors being careless – either personally or through their employees – so as to directly cause the wrong tooth to be extracted. The impacts of that error became part of the case evidence when the judge allowed the detailed chart entries of P's therapist, which described his emotional distress, to satisfy his claim of damages.

A major stance taken by Dr. Q's counsel was that she had done everything properly, and it was solely because P was careless in losing the referral card which led to the office manager's hurried documentation mistake. However, Dr. Q had performed no dentistry in a negligent fashion. Dr. E's counsel took the position that P agreed to have both teeth removed, as demonstrated by his signature and initials on a form which gave Dr. E permission to extract upper right "molars" (plural). But when the judge questioned P about the specific events involving the consent form modification, and had that confirmed by Dr. E, she disallowed the consent form in its entirety, ruling that informed consent is a pre-treatment process, which must be voluntary to be valid, and this document, in the form presented, represented neither pre-treatment nor voluntary (because by the time P initialed, he no longer had any choices).

In the end, the judge held both doctors liable, and awarded P a modest sum for the emotional distress he suffered, but nothing for actual costs, as there were none. The judge said that, even though Dr. Q did not herself, but through an employee, make a transcription error, the concept of vicarious liability meant that actions taken by Dr. Q's employee, as part of employment, were as though the erroneous actions were committed by Dr. Q. The judge then turned to Dr. E and suggested that his mid-procedure attempt, to make it seem as though this had all been planned in advance, was misleading to the court, at best. For this reason, she levied the majority of responsibility against Dr. E.

Takeaways

By way of the concept known as vicarious liability, a dentist (and/or a practice entity) is responsible for the acts of those who work under the dentist's supervision, whether that supervision is direct or simply implied. Therefore, even though Dr. Q did not perform any negligent act herself, it is as though she did. It is important for practitioners to be aware of this in the course of overseeing the actions of all of their staff members that are involved with patient contact to any degree.And it is critical that they be aware of which duties may be properly delegated and which must not. Here, had the office manager who wrote the replacement referral shown it to Dr. Q for a final sign-off, the ultimate dental error would likely have never happened. As an alternative, Dr. Q could have established office policy that would have avoided the mistake, namely making and keeping a chart copy of the referral card initially given to P. If that had been done, the office manager would have simply been able to fax a copy of what Dr. Q actually created, eliminating altogether any chance of interpersonal miscommunication. 

Informed consent is a process, often and hopefully memorialized with a signed writing, that gives a patient decision-making authority before the start of a procedure, once made aware of risks, benefits and alternatives: it is not valid aftera procedure or during the procedure, by which time there are no longer any true choices to be made. Engaging in the process any time other than prior to its start is a mere pretext, which, at least in this judge's courtroom, was legally invalid. The viewing of Dr. E's actions in this regard as misleading is not necessarily anything but the assessment of one person, who happened to be the judge. Which might well also be reflective of how jurors might view it and act. This clearly demonstrates why every part of a patient record should be created, not only truthfully, but with an eye toward who might someday read and evaluate it.

Wrong-site treatment, especially surgery, has become an increasingly frequent event among dentists in all practice areas. The "time out" concept – to assure proper patient, proper site, and patient-chart match - before a procedure starts, as our medical colleagues do well and fairly consistently, cannot be overstated as a critically important step. In doing so, all members of the team should be encouraged to alert the treating doctor, in a way that does not alarm the patient, any time something seems amiss, with no repercussions for a "false alarm.”

Finally, given dentistry's multiple and sometimes confusing tooth numbering systems, identifying a tooth by its name, rather than by a number, can provide true simplicity and better accuracy. It would be difficult to argue against the clarity of saying "upper right first molar" as compared with Universal #3 or Palmer upper right 6 or FDI 16. It's easy to clear up those muddy waters, every time. 

Summary of Takeaways

  • Staff errors can create liability for the supervising dentist under vicarious liability principles. 
  • Informed consent must be obtained before treatment, not during or after a procedure.
  • Strong communication, referral documentation, and treatment verification help prevent wrong-site treatment errors.

[post_title] => A Miscommunication Between Offices Led to the Wrong Extraction [post_excerpt] => [post_status] => publish [comment_status] => closed [ping_status] => closed [post_password] => [post_name] => a-miscommunication-between-offices-led-to-the-wrong-extraction [to_ping] => [pinged] => [post_modified] => 2026-11-17 10:21:13 [post_modified_gmt] => 2026-11-17 15:21:13 [post_content_filtered] => [post_parent] => 0 [guid] => https://medprodental.com/?p=10800 [menu_order] => 0 [post_type] => post [post_mime_type] => [comment_count] => 0 [filter] => raw ) [1] => WP_Post Object ( [ID] => 10777 [post_author] => 180159417 [post_date] => 2026-10-25 23:06:55 [post_date_gmt] => 2026-10-26 03:06:55 [post_content] =>

A high-risk patient’s request for sedation during an office-based procedure ended in a fatal outcome — and malpractice claims against multiple providers. Learn why proper patient selection, thorough medical assessment, and a safe treatment environment are essential when providing office-based sedation.

Key concepts

  • Patient dies after office-based sedation
  • When medical risk factors make treatment unsafe 
  • How communication and preparation breakdowns can lead to risk

Background facts

P was a 59-year-old bus dispatcher who was a long-time patient of Dr. C, a restorative dentist. He had lost many teeth throughout the years, leaving him edentulous on the upper and partially so on the lower. The maxillary full denture was uncomfortable and, quite frankly, embarrassing due to its regularly falling out while eating, while the mandibular partial denture was satisfactory for P. Dr. C wondered aloud at a recall visit whether P might be interested in having an all-on-4 implant/fixed prosthesis to solve his dissatisfaction. P's response was, "I'm open to anything as long as you put me to sleep." Dr. C explained that he, personally, used only local anesthesia, but there was a young, new-to-practice oral surgeon in the area who would probably be willing to come to the office to do the anesthesia while Dr. C did the dentistry. P was fully on board.

When Dr. C called, Dr. M, the oral surgeon, was also happy to do what he referred to as "a deeper level of sedation," and they agreed on a date. "Just make sure the patient has an empty stomach for at least 6 hours." Dr. M met P on the day of treatment for the first time, learning only then about P's medical history and physical status. P was 5'10" tall, weighing 280 pounds, placing him just into the morbidly obese category with a BMI of 40.2. He described that he slept with a CPAP due to sleep-study-confirmed severe obstructive sleep apnea, took oral hypoglycemic medication for type II diabetes (with A1C reported as being in the "7 range"), and an ACE inhibitor and a beta-blocker for blood pressure control. P took none of his medications when he awoke some 2 hours earlier, because Dr. C made sure to tell him “Nothing to eat or drink" that morning.

Dr. M told P that he had not been aware of his medical background and expressed his concern about sedating him in an office with little in the way of trained staff or emergency equipment. P immediately said there was no way he would go through the procedure without being asleep, to which Dr. M said that the most he would do — subject to a discussion with Dr. C — would be to more deeply sedate him at the start so that local anesthesia could be administered, and then maintain him at a lighter sedated level. Dr. M privately explained to Dr. C his real concerns about the safety of any level of sedation for this patient, to which Dr. C responded that there was no other option, and that he would not be pleased if things did not go forward. Dr. M would give an initial IV dose of Propofol, followed by maintenance with Versed and nitrous oxide/oxygen through a nasal hood.

The anesthesia record created by Dr. M classified P as an ASA II, listing his initial BP as 167/92, his oxygen saturation as 93%, a pulse rate of 85 with a sinus rhythm, and 16 respirations per minute. All monitors remained in place as P was moved to a reclined position in the chair so that Dr. C could be ready to give the local anesthesia once the initial medications took effect. Before P could count backwards from 100 to 97, he was asleep and snoring loudly. Dr. M pulled P's mandible forward, which reduced the snoring volume, but the earlier visible chest rise upon inspiration was no longer evident. The O2 saturation dropped to 89, then to 81, and then into the mid-70s, while tachycardia took over with an ever-decreasing blood pressure. Dr. M saw the situation quickly becoming grave, so he asked an assistant to call 911, but Dr. C did not want "to cause a scene," so he told the assistant to wait for a while.

When all vital signs became precipitously worse, to the point of no palpable or electronically visible pulse, paramedics were finally called while Dr. M began CPR. ACLS was not possible due to the lack of drugs and equipment, and no AED was available in the office. An Ambu bag/mask was in its original wrapper, but once taken out, nobody except Dr. M knew how to use it, and he was delivering chest compressions. Paramedics were unable to revive P, despite appropriate efforts, but P was transported to a local hospital, where he was pronounced dead. 

Legal action

P's widow was appointed the will-designated executor of P's estate. Her retained attorney quickly gathered medical records and forwarded them to experts the attorney believed would be needed to move a wrongful death case forward. The experts were unanimously critical of both Dr. C and Dr. M, for differing roles, all of which, they opined, directly contributed to P's death.

Among other things, the experts viewed Dr. C as having been negligent in failing to fully advise Dr. M of P's medical conditions, in failing to advise R regarding the taking of his usual medications before treatment, in bringing in an outside practitioner to provide sedation without having an adequate physical setup for doing so (in other words, "captaining a ship destined to likely fail"), in pressuring Dr. M into doing what he expressed he did not feel comfortable doing, and in acting so as to delay paramedics' attempts at resuscitation.

In implicating Dr. M as having been the primary actor to have caused P's death, the experts stated that he had been negligent in performing sedation in an environment that he had not fully checked in advance and which was inadequately stocked and staffed to do so safely, in performing outpatient sedation on a patient who was too medically compromised for that and then misclassifying into a more healthy characterization, in performing sedation without medical clearance, given P's status, in allowing P to be reclined, rather than being in a more upright position, and never correcting the position, in failing to have P's hemodynamic instability maximized prior to the sedation, and in acceding to the pressures of both R and Dr. C.

Pre-suit monetary settlements as to both practitioners were reached, and both were sanctioned by their state Board. 

Takeaways

Ideal or not, it is a fact of current practice that dentists, particularly specialists, travel to practices not their own to perform per diem services, often early in their careers, much like Dr. M did here. Standards of care are not lessened, or modified in any way, to reflect practicing in settings that are not on "home turf": patients are entitled to receive the same appropriate levels of care, regardless of where they are treated. The responsibility lies with the visiting doctor to check, in advance, to be certain that the setting is, first and foremost, safe for the patient, for every planned and foreseeable procedure. If not, the most risk-protective solution is to either correct the deficiencies or step away entirely, as much as either might not be the best from a practice-building standpoint.

It is beyond debate that R had a number of significant medical compromises, some of which might be viewed as contraindicating sedation (at least to the degree provided, even by the induction drug), particularly outside of a hospital setting. Once Dr. M was advised of them, albeit on the very eve of the procedure, it was up to him to have taken all necessary associated steps such as: considering medical evaluation, properly reaching an ASA status and making determinations taking that into account, establishing the roles and responsibilities for both him and his co-treater, Dr. C, and, if safety concerns warranted it, deferring care altogether.

While Dr. M delivered the sedation and took all of the clinical steps in that regard and in the lead-up, Dr. C invited all of it, so he might well be imbued with vicarious liability — responsibility for the wrongful or negligent actions of another, here the actions of Dr. M — in addition to his own direct liability for his actions, as suggested by the expert opinions discussed above. Plaintiffs can be successful in malpractice lawsuits by employing concepts of direct liability, vicarious liability, or both.

Not every patient is a candidate for every procedure. That concept certainly applies to sedation. Despite what a patient might want, or even demand, they should not necessarily have it performed, particularly if it is relatively or absolutely contraindicated. As we have said here in prior case studies, and which bears repeating here, patients have an absolute right to refuse any procedure or professional advice, but they should not be permitted to dictate what a practitioner must do: that rarely leads to anyplace good.

Summary of takeaways

  • Before treating patients, visiting providers must confirm that the treatment environment, staffing, and emergency preparedness meet the standard of care.
  • Patients with significant medical risk factors require careful evaluation, appropriate risk classification, and, when necessary, adjustments to the treatment plan.
  • Patient demands should never outweigh safety concerns. Providers must be willing to postpone or decline treatment when risks cannot be appropriately managed.

[post_title] => A Fatal Sedation Outcome Leads to Dental Board Sanctions [post_excerpt] => [post_status] => publish [comment_status] => closed [ping_status] => closed [post_password] => [post_name] => a-fatal-sedation-outcome-leads-to-dental-board-sanctions [to_ping] => [pinged] => [post_modified] => 2026-10-30 15:03:21 [post_modified_gmt] => 2026-10-30 19:03:21 [post_content_filtered] => [post_parent] => 0 [guid] => https://medprodental.com/?p=10777 [menu_order] => 0 [post_type] => post [post_mime_type] => [comment_count] => 0 [filter] => raw ) [2] => WP_Post Object ( [ID] => 10718 [post_author] => 180159417 [post_date] => 2026-08-17 02:07:45 [post_date_gmt] => 2026-08-17 06:07:45 [post_content] =>

In this real-life case study, dentists will see how a billing dispute and incomplete informed consent process escalated into a malpractice lawsuit. Learn why clear communication about treatment risks, accurate coding practices, and thoughtful handling of patient concerns are essential to reducing liability and protecting patient trust.

Key concepts

  • Dentist sued after a billing dispute and nerve injury
  • How informed consent gaps can increase malpractice risk
  • Why accurate coding and patient communication matter

Background facts

For Dr. A, extracting teeth was an everyday part of practice, as was virtually the entire scope of dentistry. In addition to postdoctoral training, she had been performing these procedures for years in a region of the state with no oral surgeons within a 2–3-hour drive. She was a participating provider in several dental insurance plans that were popular among her patients.

One such patient, P, was an 18-year-old high school senior who presented for an annual recall visit, with a new complaint of periodic pain associated with the lower right third molar. Despite P being of majority, his mother accompanied him into the treatment room to see Dr. A. Following a clinical examination, a panoramic film was taken and viewed by Dr. A. Tooth #32 was erupted, had incomplete apex formation, but was still in close radiographic proximity to the inferior alveolar canal. Dr. A assessed the pain to be a function of difficulty in cleansing the area, with inflamed gingivae as a result. She suggested, while pointing to the panoramic, extraction, which she said, "shouldn't be too hard,” although it carried a "slight risk of a nerve injury which could leave P's lower lip and chin numb, and rarely be permanent." This conversation was documented with specificity in the chart. P had heard about impacted wisdom teeth from a few friends, so he asked whether his tooth was impacted. Dr. A replied, "No, it is not.” P wanted to think about it, so he left the office with a sample of an oral rinse and instructions as to how to improve his oral hygiene. A month later, the symptoms persisted, so P's mother called the office to schedule an extraction appointment.

Before having local anesthetic injected, P was handed a paper entitled "consent form,” which he and his mother "briefly read.” The document contained a list of potential risks, including a general statement about possible "loss of sensation.” P signed the document prior to the extraction going forward. Dr. A worked on the tooth for well over an hour, much longer than she had anticipated, cutting out pieces of tooth and trimming away bone using round and fissure burs. P could taste blood, particularly at one point, which caused Dr. A to pack gauze in his mouth. The following day, P awoke to find the right half of his lower lip and chin numb, which he did not find surprising, given the warning beforehand, but so was the right half of his tongue, which was a surprise. At post-op visits, Dr. A assured and re-assured P and his mother that feeling would return to normal — it never did.

Separately, P received a bill for Dr. A's services from her billing office, seeking a co-pay for "#32 7240.” The amount was significant, despite Dr. A's advertised plan participation, so P's mother questioned the office manager as to what all of this meant. The response was that, according to the insurance plan's rules, Dr. A was permitted to charge that amount for fully impacted wisdom teeth, as this was. P's mother replied that Dr. A had specifically advised her and her son that the tooth was not impacted, no less fully so. The office manager spoke with Dr. A, but the answer came back that, because Dr. A had to work so long to remove the tooth, she was not willing to make any adjustments.

P's mother contacted the insurance carrier to explain the situation. The carrier requested a pre-treatment radiograph from Dr. A, based upon which the in-house reviewers concluded that the tooth was not appropriately coded as 7240, but rather should have been 7210 (surgical extraction of erupted tooth). Under the plan provisions, Dr. A was therefore not permitted to charge any co-pay but instead accept the plan payment in full. When the insurer notified Dr. A of that, with a copy sent to P's mother (whose employer provided the coverage), Dr. A was steadfast that she was entitled to the amount billed and would send P to collection if she was not paid. P's mother did pay the claimed balance, but the carrier dropped Dr. A from the panel due to what it referenced as "upcoding resulting in excessive billing.”

Legal action

P had slowly been adapting to the lip, chin, and tongue numbness, but his mother remained upset about the principle of billing her son and threatening a collection action, so she contacted an attorney. The attorney was not very familiar with dentistry in any legal regard, so he reached out to his own dentist, with a copy of Dr. A's records that he had been provided, to help him interpret what was going on. The dentist agreed with the insurance company's position that the extraction had been inappropriately upcoded, but perhaps more importantly that it was clear from the records that, while P had been warned of the possibility of an inferior alveolar nerve injury and its effects, he had not been told anything about tongue numbness, which came from an injury to an entirely different nerve branch and which should have been avoided if proper technique had been employed.

The attorney initiated a lawsuit against Dr. A, asserting lack of informed consent relating to the lingual nerve injury, dental malpractice regarding the causing of the lingual nerve injury, and breach of contract leading to the improperly billed (and collected) co-pay amount. The defense attorneys assigned to Dr. A by her malpractice carrier reviewed the case with their client and advised her that they would seek expert opinion as to the substance of the informed consent and malpractice claims, but that she would not be covered for the breach of contract claim, per a clearly stated policy exclusion.

The expert retained by Dr. A's counsel was provisionally willing to present a defense as to the malpractice claim regarding her having negligently caused the tongue numbness, but that position would need to be re-evaluated following her deposition testimony. However, there was no evidence in the record to demonstrate that she had provided any warning of a potential lingual nerve injury and its impacts. The defense expert did not see a pathway to successfully defend the claim of lack of informed consent. A second expert reviewer reached the same conclusion.

Dr. A's attorneys had a candid discussion with her. Even if the malpractice claim could likely be effectively defended, the lack of informed consent claim could not. So, P would be entitled to a monetary award regardless of which, or both, of the claims went P's way in the eyes of a jury. Dr. A agreed to have her attorneys seek to settle the claim, to be paid by the malpractice carrier, which they did. As part of the settlement agreement, Dr. A would personally return to P the amount his mother paid her for the co-pay. 

Takeaways

While it is impossible to know whether P would have sought an attorney at some point to file an action on his behalf based upon the substantive dental issues, it is quite clear that the issue which drove the initial attorney involvement was the billed, and eventually paid, co-pay amount. There is then perhaps a bit of irony that the money that Dr. A was unwilling to waive directly led to a settled malpractice claim, but that insisted-upon co-pay not only started the legal action steps but was also ultimately paid by Dr. A out-of-pocket. Dr. A made the decision to demand a disputed amount of money, and that decision likely cost her far more — particularly with her being dropped from a panel — than had she acquiesced in the first place. It is not our role here to advise dentists as to whether they should fervently go after unpaid, disputed fees. Instead, we demonstrate a situation where doing so ended up causing more harm than benefit. Food for thought.

Experience teaches that lay jurors might not always understand scientific, dental facts, sometimes making their determinations counter to what experts and attorneys anticipate. On the other hand, issues relating to overbilling or upcoding are relatively straightforward for plaintiffs' attorneys to explain to jurors, and simple for them to understand. At times, jurors might put all else aside and render a verdict for a plaintiff if they do not see the defendant-dentist as having been honest. Such is a version of jury nullification, with the jury members substituting what they deem critical in place of what the law says is critical. Taking subjectivity of that type out of the hands of juries increases a defendant's chances for success.

This case study exemplifies how the trigger for a patient seeking legal counsel might have nothing at all to do with the quality of dentistry. Yes, dentistry is complex, and there is an ever-present unpredictability factor, so ideal results do not happen with every procedure, with every patient. What need not be complex are matters over which dentists and their staff members have full control — such matters can virtually always be taken out of the equation as to what starts the legal ball rolling.

Finally, we briefly address the coding of procedures for billing purposes. The ADA and perhaps other associations provide numerical codes for dental procedures, which state the procedure performed and which often serve as the basis for which payment is sought and made. With few exceptions — such as 7241 for full impactions with unusual surgical complications, or time under sedation/general anesthesia, as examples — procedure codes do not take into account the length of time required to complete or the difficulty in doing so. To upcode to a procedure not actually performed, for a higher fee, is to invite a host of problems, including the initiation of a malpractice lawsuit or Dental Board complaint.

Summary of takeaways

  • A signed consent form alone is not enough — patients should also be verbally informed of all risks, benefits and alternatives associated with a procedure, by way of back and forth conversations, and those discussions should be thoroughly documented.
  • Billing disputes and inaccurate procedure coding can damage patient trust and may become the catalyst for malpractice claims.
  • Upcoding procedures can result in payer disputes, loss of network participation, regulatory concerns, and increased legal exposure.

[post_title] => Billing Dispute and Consent Issues Lead to Malpractice Lawsuit [post_excerpt] => [post_status] => publish [comment_status] => closed [ping_status] => closed [post_password] => [post_name] => billing-dispute-and-consent-issues-lead-to-malpractice-lawsuit [to_ping] => [pinged] => [post_modified] => 2026-08-27 12:28:03 [post_modified_gmt] => 2026-08-27 16:28:03 [post_content_filtered] => [post_parent] => 0 [guid] => https://medprodental.com/?p=10718 [menu_order] => 0 [post_type] => post [post_mime_type] => [comment_count] => 0 [filter] => raw ) ) [post_count] => 3 [current_post] => -1 [before_loop] => 1 [in_the_loop] => [post] => WP_Post Object ( [ID] => 10800 [post_author] => 180159417 [post_date] => 2026-11-04 14:02:38 [post_date_gmt] => 2026-11-04 19:02:38 [post_content] =>

In this real-life case study, dentists will learn how a simple communication breakdown between offices led to the extraction of the wrong tooth and a malpractice lawsuit. Discover the roles that referral processes, informed consent, team communication, and treatment verification play in preventing wrong-site treatment and reducing liability.

Key Concepts

  • Wrong-tooth extraction results in lawsuit
  • Communication breakdown leads to treatment error
  • Preventing liability through verification procedures

Background Facts

Dr. Q is a restorative dentist in a suburban community. While she used to practice the full spectrum of general dentistry, the last few years have seen her focus exclusively on restorative cases, with patients needing all other areas of dental care being referred to other providers. P was a 37-year-old man who had been a patient of Dr. Q's for nearly a decade.

During a weekend soccer game, P "headed" the ball to one of his teammates, with the ball striking the right mid-face, somewhat lower than the forehead area he had intended. There was some lingering pain on P's face for the remainder of the game, but he did not think much of it. At dinner that evening, he found himself with shock-like discomfort emanating from his upper right teeth, although he could not pinpoint a specific tooth as the source. When the situation did not resolve by several days later, he presented to see Dr. Q.

When Dr. Q examined the quadrant, she noted tooth #2 to have a large 3-surface amalgam in place, but she could not elicit any abnormal responses through percussion or palpation. Nor could she find anything unusual on radiograph or with an explorer. On the other hand, #3, which was a virgin tooth, was tender to all modalities and it clinically exhibited a probable vertical MB root fracture beginning at the furcation and extending apically. Dr. Q concluded the tooth to be non-restorable, so she suggested its extraction – by an oral surgeon – with an implant and crown for replacement. Dr. Q entered her electronic note, explaining the situation regarding both teeth #2 and 3, and handing P a handwritten referral card, asking Dr. E, an oral and maxillofacial surgeon, to extract #3 and place a bone graft so that she (Dr. Q) could later place an implant and restore it.

Dr. Q's front desk staff member called Dr. E's office to say that "we're sending over a patient, P, for an extraction.” "OK.” Either before or during the short drive to see Dr. E, P misplaced or lost the referral card. At this point, all he knew was that an upper right tooth needed to come out. P "frantically" called Dr. Q's office to ask that a fax be sent to Dr. E with the information as to the tooth to be extracted. Dr. Q's office manager quickly scanned the newly written note from just a few minutes prior, focused solely on the first portion of the chart entry which stated that tooth #2 had a "large, old MOD amalgam,” presumed that was the tooth in need of treatment, and faxed "please ext tooth #2,” unsigned, on Dr. Q's letterhead. After taking a periapical radiograph of teeth #1-3 (distal half only of #3 captured), obtaining P's signature on a consent form for "extraction upper right molar,” and giving local anesthesia, Dr. E did exactly what the letter from Dr. Q asked him to do. A post-extraction periapical more clearly and completely showed tooth #3, adjacent to the new extraction site, with an apparent vertical MB root fracture.

Dr. E immediately called Dr. Q after realizing his error, and the two concluded that he ought to explain the event to P, and then extract tooth #3. Dr. E asked P to initial the newly modified consent form, which added the letter "s" to "molar.” P complied. Drs. Q and E would work together to provide 2 implants with 2 crowns, all at no cost. Those treatments later went forward uneventfully, with P being able to function without limitation, although he always worried about his dental future. (It is worth noting that P had been in family therapy – for totally unrelated reasons – prior to these events, but he began to talk extensively with his therapist about his upset over the dentistry, with all of that recorded in the therapy chart).

Legal Action

P was clearly aware that he would have no out-of-pocket expenses due to the wrongly extracted tooth. In fact, whereas he would have paid for the 1 implant and 1 crown for tooth #3 had there been no error, he no longer had to, based upon the goodwill gestures of both doctors. But it was no longer about money needed for the dentistry: he wanted to be compensated for the stress of the entire situation. P was unable to find an attorney willing to take his case against Drs. Q and E, so he decided to file a malpractice lawsuit in City Court, which in his jurisdiction, was a level higher than Small Claims and a level lower than the general trial court, and which readily enabled him to handle the case on his own, as a pro se litigant. The City Court's "DIY" web page set out the procedures to abide by, the most important of which was a reasonable degree of relaxation of rules of evidence. For example, copies of medical and dental records could be introduced without the author being present to testify about, and certify, them. A judge would preside and would render a verdict.

At the trial, both of the defendant doctors were represented by attorneys assigned to them by their malpractice insurers, as malpractice policies generally provide, regardless of the level of the court. P argued, essentially, that he was an unwitting victim, with no role in any wrongdoing, but with both doctors being careless – either personally or through their employees – so as to directly cause the wrong tooth to be extracted. The impacts of that error became part of the case evidence when the judge allowed the detailed chart entries of P's therapist, which described his emotional distress, to satisfy his claim of damages.

A major stance taken by Dr. Q's counsel was that she had done everything properly, and it was solely because P was careless in losing the referral card which led to the office manager's hurried documentation mistake. However, Dr. Q had performed no dentistry in a negligent fashion. Dr. E's counsel took the position that P agreed to have both teeth removed, as demonstrated by his signature and initials on a form which gave Dr. E permission to extract upper right "molars" (plural). But when the judge questioned P about the specific events involving the consent form modification, and had that confirmed by Dr. E, she disallowed the consent form in its entirety, ruling that informed consent is a pre-treatment process, which must be voluntary to be valid, and this document, in the form presented, represented neither pre-treatment nor voluntary (because by the time P initialed, he no longer had any choices).

In the end, the judge held both doctors liable, and awarded P a modest sum for the emotional distress he suffered, but nothing for actual costs, as there were none. The judge said that, even though Dr. Q did not herself, but through an employee, make a transcription error, the concept of vicarious liability meant that actions taken by Dr. Q's employee, as part of employment, were as though the erroneous actions were committed by Dr. Q. The judge then turned to Dr. E and suggested that his mid-procedure attempt, to make it seem as though this had all been planned in advance, was misleading to the court, at best. For this reason, she levied the majority of responsibility against Dr. E.

Takeaways

By way of the concept known as vicarious liability, a dentist (and/or a practice entity) is responsible for the acts of those who work under the dentist's supervision, whether that supervision is direct or simply implied. Therefore, even though Dr. Q did not perform any negligent act herself, it is as though she did. It is important for practitioners to be aware of this in the course of overseeing the actions of all of their staff members that are involved with patient contact to any degree.And it is critical that they be aware of which duties may be properly delegated and which must not. Here, had the office manager who wrote the replacement referral shown it to Dr. Q for a final sign-off, the ultimate dental error would likely have never happened. As an alternative, Dr. Q could have established office policy that would have avoided the mistake, namely making and keeping a chart copy of the referral card initially given to P. If that had been done, the office manager would have simply been able to fax a copy of what Dr. Q actually created, eliminating altogether any chance of interpersonal miscommunication. 

Informed consent is a process, often and hopefully memorialized with a signed writing, that gives a patient decision-making authority before the start of a procedure, once made aware of risks, benefits and alternatives: it is not valid aftera procedure or during the procedure, by which time there are no longer any true choices to be made. Engaging in the process any time other than prior to its start is a mere pretext, which, at least in this judge's courtroom, was legally invalid. The viewing of Dr. E's actions in this regard as misleading is not necessarily anything but the assessment of one person, who happened to be the judge. Which might well also be reflective of how jurors might view it and act. This clearly demonstrates why every part of a patient record should be created, not only truthfully, but with an eye toward who might someday read and evaluate it.

Wrong-site treatment, especially surgery, has become an increasingly frequent event among dentists in all practice areas. The "time out" concept – to assure proper patient, proper site, and patient-chart match - before a procedure starts, as our medical colleagues do well and fairly consistently, cannot be overstated as a critically important step. In doing so, all members of the team should be encouraged to alert the treating doctor, in a way that does not alarm the patient, any time something seems amiss, with no repercussions for a "false alarm.”

Finally, given dentistry's multiple and sometimes confusing tooth numbering systems, identifying a tooth by its name, rather than by a number, can provide true simplicity and better accuracy. It would be difficult to argue against the clarity of saying "upper right first molar" as compared with Universal #3 or Palmer upper right 6 or FDI 16. It's easy to clear up those muddy waters, every time. 

Summary of Takeaways

  • Staff errors can create liability for the supervising dentist under vicarious liability principles. 
  • Informed consent must be obtained before treatment, not during or after a procedure.
  • Strong communication, referral documentation, and treatment verification help prevent wrong-site treatment errors.

[post_title] => A Miscommunication Between Offices Led to the Wrong Extraction [post_excerpt] => [post_status] => publish [comment_status] => closed [ping_status] => closed [post_password] => [post_name] => a-miscommunication-between-offices-led-to-the-wrong-extraction [to_ping] => [pinged] => [post_modified] => 2026-11-17 10:21:13 [post_modified_gmt] => 2026-11-17 15:21:13 [post_content_filtered] => [post_parent] => 0 [guid] => https://medprodental.com/?p=10800 [menu_order] => 0 [post_type] => post [post_mime_type] => [comment_count] => 0 [filter] => raw ) [comment_count] => 0 [current_comment] => -1 [found_posts] => 86 [max_num_pages] => 29 [max_num_comment_pages] => 0 [is_single] => [is_preview] => [is_page] => [is_archive] => 1 [is_date] => [is_year] => [is_month] => [is_day] => [is_time] => [is_author] => [is_category] => 1 [is_tag] => [is_tax] => [is_search] => [is_feed] => [is_comment_feed] => [is_trackback] => [is_home] => [is_privacy_policy] => [is_404] => [is_embed] => [is_paged] => [is_admin] => [is_attachment] => [is_singular] => [is_robots] => [is_favicon] => [is_sitemap] => [is_posts_page] => [is_post_type_archive] => [query_vars_hash:WP_Query:private] => 75778200ac09d3ac15185dc177768cfc [query_vars_changed:WP_Query:private] => [thumbnails_cached] => [allow_query_attachment_by_filename:protected] => [stopwords:WP_Query:private] => [compat_fields:WP_Query:private] => Array ( [0] => query_vars_hash [1] => query_vars_changed ) [compat_methods:WP_Query:private] => Array ( [0] => init_query_flags [1] => parse_tax_query ) [query_cache_key:WP_Query:private] => wp_query:32d226fad6a9a4c0c54311f7e76d3e50 )

Additional Risk Tips content

A communication breakdown between dental offices led to the extraction of the wrong tooth and a malpractice lawsuit. Learn key risk management lessons on referrals, informed consent, vicarious liability, and treatment verification.

A routine sedation case became a wrongful death lawsuit when medical risks, safety concerns, and emergency preparedness failures were ignored.

See how a billing dispute, upcoding concerns, and informed consent gaps led to a dental malpractice lawsuit and costly legal consequences.

This document does not constitute legal or medical advice and should not be construed as rules or establishing a standard of care. Because the facts applicable to your situation may vary, or the laws applicable in your jurisdiction may differ, please contact your attorney or other professional advisors if you have any questions related to your legal or medical obligations or rights, state or federal laws, contract interpretation, or other legal questions.

MedPro Group is the marketing name used to refer to the insurance operations of The Medical Protective Company, Princeton Insurance Company, PLICO, Inc. and MedPro RRG Risk Retention Group. All insurance products are underwritten and administered by these and other Berkshire Hathaway affiliates, including National Fire & Marine Insurance Company. Product availability is based upon business and/or regulatory approval and/or may differ among companies.

© MedPro Group Inc. All rights reserved.